Lunchbox's wife ordered 5 sandwiches and 5 bags of chips from a sandwich shop. On his way home from work, he swung by to pick up the food.
When he showed up, there were 5 sandwiches in the bag and lots of napkins. He didn't see any chips, so he grabbed 5 bags of chips from the rack in the shop. Well, when he got home he realized there were 5 bags of chips UNDER the sandwiches, so now he had 10 bags of chips.
He asked The Bobby Bones Show if he stole. The show all collectively said yes, but it wasn't an intentional steal. However, it was on him to do his due diligence to check the entirety of the bag, which he didn't. Lunchbox admitted he didn't even go to look under the sandwiches because logically, why would someone put chips under sandwiches? He used to work at Jason's Deli and they would always put chips on the top of the bag so the chips don't get crushed.
Lunchbox wanted to know if the show members would return the 5 bags of chips after noticing. Amy said she would the next time she was near the shop, but wouldn't immediately go back. Bobby would try to pay for the chips the next time he was in the shop. However, Lunchbox admitted he didn't return them, his family just ate them. He did have to explain to his kids that he didn't steal and it was an accident.